Stanner: loaded green bean fries.
The Master/Captain Jack Harkness: Death By Chocolate cake with raspberry and dark chocolate frosting.
Destiel: grilled angel food cake with spiced berries
Dale and Audrey from Twin Peaks: cherry rhubarb pie
suggested by hueylewisrises
Janto: Coffee milkshake with more whipped cream than is healthy, and rainbow sprinkles.